● Media articles over the last few days have carried reports on the
likely recommendations of the Dr. Kirit Parikh committee on fuel
pricing in India. These suggest the committee may recommend
trade parity pricing of fuels be continued, contrary to expectations.
● In addition these also suggest the monthly increment in diesel retail
prices may be increased to Rs.1–1.5/ltr, and that upstream
companies pay 85% of profits made on crude as subsidy. There is a
risk that these media reports are incorrect, or that recommendations
are changed before publication, and around report acceptance.
● We estimated (here) that the IOC/BPCL/HPCL stocks are pricing in
the impact of export parity pricing by trading at 0.2–0.3x core book.
If this is taken off the table, there may be a near-term stock relief
even though FY14 RoE remains dependent on govt. payments.
● Any impact on upstream will depend on adoption of the new payment
formula, and the calculation of crude production costs. Back of
envelope calculations suggest net realisations for ONGC should not
change much. Clarity on payments can help multiples expand. In this
space, we have OUTPERFORM ratings on ONGC, BPCL and GAIL.
likely recommendations of the Dr. Kirit Parikh committee on fuel
pricing in India. These suggest the committee may recommend
trade parity pricing of fuels be continued, contrary to expectations.
● In addition these also suggest the monthly increment in diesel retail
prices may be increased to Rs.1–1.5/ltr, and that upstream
companies pay 85% of profits made on crude as subsidy. There is a
risk that these media reports are incorrect, or that recommendations
are changed before publication, and around report acceptance.
● We estimated (here) that the IOC/BPCL/HPCL stocks are pricing in
the impact of export parity pricing by trading at 0.2–0.3x core book.
If this is taken off the table, there may be a near-term stock relief
even though FY14 RoE remains dependent on govt. payments.
● Any impact on upstream will depend on adoption of the new payment
formula, and the calculation of crude production costs. Back of
envelope calculations suggest net realisations for ONGC should not
change much. Clarity on payments can help multiples expand. In this
space, we have OUTPERFORM ratings on ONGC, BPCL and GAIL.